Welcome Sign out
Shopping Cart My Account Order History Sign in Not yet a member? Help

Book Printing

greyscale print quality?

I am making a gift for my brothers and sisters of our fathers photography. My father is dieing and I really want to make someting very special out of his life times work can I just ask what the black and white print quality is like – does it seem tinted at all or not – i really need an honest oppinion because my fathers book is huge and I will be paying for five copies in time for christmas and I am disabled so money is very tight.

 Please give an honest oppinion.

Kindest Regards

Rosie  

Replytopic_b_normal
Posted by
Rosie1
Sep 6, 2007 1:49pm PST
Permalink
Rosie1
 

Hi!

Sad to hear about your dad. Is he a photographer?

Honestly – I was happy with the B&W pages I’ve got. Now, they aren’t up to the quality of some fine art photo books I have, but the blurb printing was almost always completely free of tint and the tonal gradations are quite respectable. Maybe those few with a subtlest of magenta tinge would annoy you? I can’t say. But the first thing I thought when seeing these shots in my book was "wow, these look great" – and I used to spend a fair amount of time in a darkroom, and I do care about quality.

 Hope this helps.

Mark 

Posted by
Claustral
Sep 6, 2007 2:15pm PST
Permalink
Claustral
 

thank you for your reply. My dad and I are both photographers – I had an exhibition recently and had to return a couple of prints because of tinting in the greyscale – it would be such a shame to  return an entire book.

Posted by
Rosie1
Sep 6, 2007 3:05pm PST
Permalink
Rosie1
 

Hi

I just printed a B&W test book. The point being that each image is in more than once.

I find that the image on the back of the physical pages differs in tint from the image on the front of the same page. I guess that this means they run the pages thru, turn them over and print the back on a second pass and that the two passes differ slightly. Some variation is to be expected of course, but when two variations show at once it is more noticeable.

I think that I would make the images slightly sepia to counteract any cyan tint. While this book is a portfolio and I need to use every page, front and back, for a “real one” I would probably put text, poetry or “blankness” :) on the back of each physical pagel.

Scott

Posted by
scottgraham
Sep 8, 2007 11:34am PST
Permalink
scottgraham
 

I recently had my first book, a softcover 8×10 printed. I have about 10 B&W images printed full page.

To my surprise I was happier with these than most of the colour images. They were neutral, and the ‘graininess’ of the Blurb printing process seemed appropriate and mixed in with the grain in the B&W images.

There was no appreciable tint in these pages. However, I think that there is no absolute guarantee that there won’t be tinting because other people have experienced it.

What I would say, is that Blurb is so much cheaper than other options that you can make several books for the price of 1 of the others. So you would still be winning on price if you had to make twice as many blurb books and throw half of them away. Perhaps its best to buy one at a time as the printer may behave differently on different runs.

Posted by
free1000
Sep 8, 2007 12:50pm PST
Permalink
free1000
 

... this morning, probably under different lighting I noticed that there is a very slight tint to the B&W images.

This tinting is very slight, the image on the left hand page has a very subtle shift to green. The other page looks neutral.

However, I don’t think a typical viewer would ever notice this, its too subtle. I have spent a lot of time looking for metamerism effects on my inkjet prints, so I tend to notice this kind of thing even when its very subtle. I would doubt that most people would notice.

I won’t know what the consistency is like until I’ve had a few more copies printed. So far though I’ve shown the book to a few people including some of my architectural clients and they have all paid compliments. The only criticism has been my cover design, and thats partly the fault of the Blurb software being unable to support my custom fonts.

Posted by
free1000
Sep 9, 2007 4:07am PST
Permalink
free1000